Judge John Roach has been recused from the case of Karmelo Anthony due to an interview, and a new judge is now set to hear Anthony's bid for a new trial, with his appearance in court noted as 'different'.

Judge John Roach is facing scrutiny for a surprising remark he made about Austin Metcalf, the killer in the Karmelo Anthony murder trial, calling him a 'nice young man'.

Following his murder conviction, Karmelo Anthony's legal team has filed motions to remove Judge John Roach from the case and to secure a new murder trial, citing constitutional arguments.

Judge John Roach defended his decision to bar cameras from the Karmelo Anthony murder trial, stating it was an "easy decision" necessary to ensure a fair trial for all parties involved.

The release of new videos, photos, and 911 calls by Judge John Roach on June 20 has triggered false social media narratives suggesting Karmelo Anthony's innocence.